I have always been a little bewildered by the use of the bayonet. Medical statistics might show us that they were almost never used; however, these naturally suffer from survivorship bias, especially in bayonet engagements, where, as Captain Soloviev put it, there are only living victors and dead vanquished; and while we do read of counts of dead killed by the bayonet in after-action reports, this too does not show us the full picture, as we might say these single events are extreme outliers. To prove my point I think, "A Comparative study of World War casualties from gas and other weapons" (1928) puts the number of AEF casualties in the First World War caused by the bayonet at but 235; but only 4 died from their wounds. Lewis Millett's fateful charge, which killed some twenty with the bayonet, caused five times the bayonet deaths in a single day, than what we might suppose (taking those aid station statistics at face value) the US Army in WWI suffered in 19 months.
Pages
- Home
- Assortment of Quotes: Index
- "They all hold swords, being expert in war" - The Sword in Combat
- The Sword in Combat - Battles and Summaries
- Is Halfswording Actually Required for Armored Fencing?
- "He put a vail on his face" - Pikemen with Closed Helmets
- A Small Statistical Analysis of the Bayonet in the Korean War
- (WIP) "Great cutting curtilaces" - The Heavy Falchion of the Man at Arms
- (WIP) Romans Fighting Unconventionally
- The Axe of the 14th Century Man at Arms
- (WIP) Shortened Lances
- Weapons at the Knight's Saddle
- Omdurman and the Knightly Charge
- The Role of the Two Handed Sword in War
- (WIP) High Medieval Infantry Tactics
- (WIP) "Ung bon coustilleur" - The Arming and Role of the Coustillier
Featured Post
The Sword in Combat - Battles and Summaries
This is a companion to my other post . Each battle listed here is a description of swords and sidearms being used en masse , detailed in a m...
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)